Paybis CMO Paul Afshar on trust, talent and the limits of AI

Paul Afshar, CMO of Paybis, markets fintech and crypto products by starting with the person behind the customer. He explains how customer conversations showed him that trust sets providers apart, why companies in broadcast mode fail to earn it and where AI falls short for marketers today.

Paul Afshar on KNOWN by INPUT Global

KNOWN by INPUT Global · Ep. 08 ft. Paul Afshar, CMO of Paybis

Selling the person behind the customer

Paul’s approach starts with the human pain points behind every customer, even in B2B, such as worrying about the next promotion or about being fired. In one of his previous roles, instead of accounting software, his team sold time, so accountants could get time back to help businesses grow and to spend with their families.

He has little patience for clinical marketing language like “ICP.”

“What we’re really talking about, even in B2B marketing, is humans.” – Paul Afshar

Research helps, but Paul puts more weight on meeting customers directly. When he starts a new role, he listens to sales calls to hear real objections and pain points. He visits B2B and B2C customers over coffee or dinner. In a couple of roles, he set up customer boards of 10 to 20 people who meet quarterly.

When every provider looks the same

In a previous role, conversations with payment and operations directors at large e-commerce and fintech businesses showed Paul that trust was a deciding factor when choosing a payment provider. Providers in payments, fintech and crypto largely offer the same service.

“The real difference is in the trust.” – Paul Afshar

His experience with talent includes Steven Bartlett, Steve Wozniak and Tim Berners-Lee. He says names at that level only work with companies they trust, so belief has to run both ways. His teams sold them on the mission behind the product, such as democratizing access to payments. Because they believed in the mission, their endorsements came across as authentic.

Companies that broadcast instead of engaging

Paul sees 3 reasons companies fail to build trust. The first is that they stay in broadcast mode instead of engaging. He compares it to a man standing in the middle of a motorway with a traffic cone, shouting while no one listens.

“Companies who broadcast don’t build trust. Companies who engage build trust.” – Paul Afshar

The second is the medium. Content from an anonymous social media account carries far less weight than content from a real person. Paul also believes the bulk of a company’s messaging should not come from the CEO or founder, since people trust a social media manager or an operations lead more than a CEO.

The third is focusing on what the company wants to say. Founders and product teams often describe their technology in terms their audience cannot follow. Paul says they should start from what the audience wants to understand or learn.

“It’s not about what you want to say, it’s about what people want to hear.” – Paul Afshar

AI’s limits for marketers today

Paul calls himself an AI maximalist only in the sense that adoption is inevitable. In his view, fundamental disruption to the industry is still years away.

“The velocity of acceleration is huge. The velocity of value created by that is almost flat.” – Paul Afshar

A polished AI avatar video asking people to buy crypto from an unknown company would not be believed, because it lacks authenticity. Paul argues that the promised layoffs and productivity gains have not arrived. For now, AI saves time and makes some tasks easier.

The CMO’s job is judgment

What Paul wants from AI is help with data. Pulling information from multiple sources, making it comparable and analyzing it is still a manual and clunky process. He sees the core qualities of future marketing leaders as creativity, judgment and taste, with AI handling the collection work that comes before them.

“AI isn’t selling to AI, AI will be selling to humans. Human dynamics, human psychology doesn’t change.” – Paul Afshar

Watch the full episode on KNOWN by INPUT Global